Before I go off on a tangent that goes against the
grain of modern day fly fishing (and I am in fact in most cases
a "Technologist" by nature!), let me acknowledge that
"Weight Forward" (WF) fly lines now outsell "Double
Taper" (DT) fly lines by at least twenty to one! However, regardless
of the trends in the industry, I personally feel that Double Taper
fly lines still have a legitimate place in the modern Fly Fishing
world.
While modern WF lines come in models that mimic
the performance of DT lines within a specific casting range (i.e.,
long front tapers and belly's), they all have their limits and eventually
you will reach out beyond the "Rear Taper" thus unleashing
the "Weight Forward" effect. In these circumstances, it
is difficult at best to deliver a fly without creating some level
of disturbance in the surface (a potential negative on Stillwater).
WF lines are constructed using a "Front Tape/Belly/rear
Taper/Running Line" configuration while DT lines employ a "Front
Tape/Belly/Rear Taper" design (i.e., the "Belly"
is the "Running Line"). The simple concept of DT lines
is that you have a continuous and even "Belly/Running Line"
that helps "Roll Over" line at all distances. This allows
the angler to deliver the fly in a very delicate manner.
In addition, DT lines tend to float better due to
the larger diameter "Belly/Running Line". This can aid
the angler in regard to picking the line up off the surface to recast
without creating a lot of disturbance or drowning your fly. Even
on moving water this can be an advantage when it comes to long line
mending (a requirement for properly presenting a fly across multiple
micro-currents in moving water).
While Weight Forward lines will unquestionably help
you throw more line (i.e., the thinner "Running" line
of a WT results in less friction than the thicker "Belly/Running
Line" of a DT), it comes with some potentially undesirable
effects as noted above. Conversely, DT lines take up far more space
on the reel thus limiting the amount of backing you can use.
As a rule, I use WF lines for most of my River and
Stream fishing (the exceptions being very light lines which I use
for Dry Fly fishing only - PRESENTATION!). When I am "Nymphing",
I rarely fish beyond the taper and this allows me to throw "Emergers"
long distances where presentation is not a factor. In addition,
the WF allows me to "push" out line with a minimal number
of back casts (keeps me out of the trees!)
For Stillwater fishing on lakes and ponds, the DT
is my line of choice. While I may lose a few feet in regard to distance,
I feel that I gain a level of presentation and line control that
in my opinion is critical to fooling wary fish. In addition, I have
the luxury of making a series of "Double Hauls" without
worrying about what's behind me in order to reach that cruising
trout just out of reach of my normal casting range.
Note: While certainly attractive
to the "Budget Minded" angler (and a legitimate option),
I have never once reversed a DT line to get an extra season or two
out of it. In addition, in a controlled environment the difference
in casting distance between a WF and DT is not what you may think.
However, you can certainly get there quicker with a WF which is
a real issue when working around trees!